Steele’s Comments Won’t Cost Him Chairmanship, Just Donors
In what will only serve as additional ammunition for his more socially conservative detractors, RNC chief Michael Steele split with the party faithful and took a decidedly controversial position: That homosexuality was not, in his opinion, a choice.
“I don’t think I’ve ever really subscribed to [the] view [that homosexuality is a choice], that you can turn it on and off like a water tap,” he said in a recent interview with GQ’s Lisa DePaulo. Even going so far as comparing the static nature of sexuality to race, he said, “You just can’t simply say, oh, like, ‘Tomorrow morning I’m gonna’ stop being gay.’ It’s like saying, ‘Tomorrow morning I’m gonna’ stop being black.’”
Steele’s comments, while seemingly refreshing to moderate GOP members, highlight a serious concern among the fledgling chairman’s critics. His proclivity for embarrassing gaffes is forcing the RNC’s skeleton crew to work double-time to salvage what remains of his once sterling reputation as a polished spokesman.
“Lest we forget, communication was supposed to be his strongest suit,” writes an irritated Phil Klein. But why, then, must we be inundated with stories of clearly avoidable mistakes? Klein argues that Steele’s desire to portray a moderate-friendly image at all times, even at the cost of abandoning his own principles, results in the delivery of a “completely muddled message.”
Just yesterday morning Steele and the RNC were faced with the rumors that SCGOP Chair Katon Dawson was quietly gathering support among fellow committee members to hold a vote of no confidence after the NY20 special election, regardless of the outcome. Dawson has since emphatically denied the speculative “anonymous rumor,” but Steele’s comments yesterday will likely serve to embolden his rivals.
Greatly working to Steele’s advantage are the institutional challenges to ousting a sitting chairman. According to the rules adopted at the party’s convention earlier last year, Rule 5 states, “The chairman or co-chairman may be removed from office only by a two-thirds (2/3) vote of the entire Republican National Committee.” Then, of course, is the public relations challenge to forcibly expelling the GOP’s first African American chairman – a move only the politically tone-deaf wouldn’t wince at.
Steele holds the chairmanship, and barring celestial intervention, that isn’t like to change anytime soon.
The problem for Steele, then, is not the potential for expulsion from his current post, but rather the extent to which these highly-publicized gaffes will upset the party’s fundraising. His predecessor, Mike Duncan, earned a reputation as a prolific fundraiser; consequently committee members will expect similar results from a chairman whose celebrity easily dwarfs the camera-shy Duncan.
Steele’s comments on abortion, of which I add were the most confusing from the GQ interview, will squarely pit him against social conservative activists and donors. And as such, he’s playing fast and loose with the committee’s large and small dolor donor database. March 20th — the release of the FEC fundraising report –will likely be the first of many bad days in the Steele administration, especially if he intends to keep poking the base in the eye with sharp objects.
By way of offering advice to Chairman Steele, a fellow RNC veteran quips, “He should be like Obama and carry his teleprompters wherever he goes.”
For obvious racial reasons, parallels between President Barack Obama and Steele have been drawn many a time. A more honest depiction, perhaps, would be to that of his loquacious side kick, the wordiest man in Washington – Vice President Joe Biden.
UPDATE: Ed Morrissey, noting Steele’s comments on abortion mark his third reversal in his short tenure as chairman, says Chairman Steele is “a lot less media savvy than most of us thought. And since he doesn’t seem to have much skill in organization, we have to ask ourselves why we should support his continued tenure as RNC chair.”
UPDATE II: Steele’s GQ interview was conducted on February 24th — four days before his spat with Rush Limbaugh. The case can and will be made by Steele’s advisors that this was an early misstep as the new chairman worked to earn his sea legs in a rough squall. Tough sell, if you ask me, for the candidate who was pitched as the most polished Republican communicator among his many competitors for the top GOP post.

Steele should (and probably does) see this as an opportunity.
If I were him, I’d build a highly qualified organization, build a team to focus on redistricting and the census, and enlist Party veterans as Regional Spokespersons.
We need to show our qualification and diversity.
Let’s rebuild.
Mr. Steele needs to be very careful. I understand that the so-called social conservative have been deemed the as part of the “lunatic fringe”, but it has been those folks that have continued to support the party so oh so many years. Holding them off at arms length in order not to alienate moderates in the party, that frankly are more likely to vote for the other side, seems a dangerous line to walk.
[...] For obvious racial reasons, parallels between President Barack Obama and Steele have been drawn many a time. A more honest depiction, perhaps, would be to that of his loquacious side kick, the wordiest man in Washington – Vice President Joe Biden.[...]
I don’t know if he has the charisma to pull it off, but I would like to see Steele more aggressively press his version of what “Republican” further into the mainstream version. It would do wonders for the party and for the country. The far right is the scariest thing in our country.
[...] rebounding from a series of gaffes and provocative interviews, Steele saw NY-20 as a means to change the narrative. He elected to up the ante and raise the [...]
[...] rebounding from a series of gaffes and provocative interviews, Steele saw NY-20 as a means to change the narrative. He elected to up the ante and raise the [...]
[...] rebounding from a series of gaffes and provocative interviews, Steele saw NY-20 as a means to change the narrative. He elected to up the ante and raise the [...]
[...] Cross-posted at http://www.Skepticians.com. Sphere: Related Content Share on: Facebook | digg_url = ‘http://www.redstate.com/jrichardson/2009/03/12/steeles-comments-wont-cost-him-chairmanship-just-donors/’; digg_title = ‘Steele’s Comments Won’t Cost Him Chairmanship, Just Donors’; digg_skin = ‘compact’; | Reddit Category: Abortion, Gay rights, GQ, Katon Dawson, Michael Steele, Michael Steele: Trainwreck media can’t look away from, Mike Duncan, Popcorn futures skyrocket, RNC [...]
[...] The Skepticians by James Richardson » Blog Archive » Steele’s Comments Won’t Cost Him Chairman… skepticians.com/steeles-comments-wont-cost-him-chairmanship-just-donors – view page – cached An independent, conservative-leaning blog providing thoughtful commentary, coverage, and insight on political, sports, and entertainment news. — From the page [...]